About SettleMyCompCase.com
32 Years Fighting for Pennsylvania Workers
This resource was built by a Pennsylvania workers' compensation attorney who has spent three decades watching insurance companies shortchange injured workers — and decided to do something about it.
David R. Cherry
Pennsylvania Workers' Compensation Attorney
David R. Cherry founded Cherry Injury Law on a straightforward belief: seriously injured people deserve dedicated, experienced representation — and a real person to answer their calls. Over three decades of practice, he has handled thousands of Pennsylvania workers' compensation cases, from initial claims through complex settlement negotiations and contested hearings before Workers' Compensation Judges.
His experience spans every phase of the workers' compensation system — denied claims, benefit termination petitions, Independent Medical Exam disputes, employer retaliation, and Compromise & Release negotiations. He has recovered tens of millions of dollars for injured Pennsylvania workers across every industry: construction, healthcare, manufacturing, transportation, and more.
SettleMyCompCase.com was built to share what David has learned over 30 years about how workers' compensation settlements are valued — and why injured workers so often leave money on the table. The insurance industry has teams of adjusters, lawyers, and doctors working to minimize what they pay. This site exists to level that playing field.
Super Lawyers
Peer-recognized distinction awarded to the top attorneys in Pennsylvania
Avvo Rating 10.0
Highest possible rating on Avvo, reflecting experience, industry recognition, and professional conduct
Best of DELCO
Recognized among the best attorneys in Delaware County, Pennsylvania
Main Line's Top Lawyers
Selected among the top lawyers serving the Philadelphia Main Line region
Proprietary Methodology
The Cherry Valuation System
Eight factors that determine what a Pennsylvania workers' comp case is actually worth — and why the insurance company's number is almost never the right one
Thirty years of settling Pennsylvania workers' compensation cases taught one lesson above all others: carriers enter every negotiation with a number designed to protect their bottom line, not yours. The Cherry Valuation System is a structured, eight-factor framework built to establish the true value of a claim before a single dollar is put on the table. Know your number first. Negotiate from there.
Nature and Permanence of the Injury
Every valuation starts here. An injury that resolves completely carries a fundamentally different value than one that leaves a permanent mark on your body and your ability to work. Surgical records, diagnostic imaging, and functional capacity evaluations establish the medical baseline — and objective evidence always outweighs a carrier's IME doctor.
Correctly Calculated Average Weekly Wage
Your weekly benefit — and the multiplier used to value your entire claim — flows directly from your average weekly wage. Carriers routinely get this wrong, excluding overtime pay, seasonal bonuses, and income from a second job. Catching and correcting those errors can meaningfully change the settlement floor before negotiations even begin.
Lost Earning Capacity Over Time
A permanent impairment at 38 represents a very different economic loss than the same impairment at 61. Remaining work life, education level, transferable skills, and the realistic job market in your area all shape what a lifetime of reduced earning capacity is actually worth in present-day dollars.
Projected Cost of Future Medical Care
A Compromise & Release extinguishes your right to future medical benefits along with your wage loss claim. That means every anticipated surgery, injection series, physical therapy course, prescription, and piece of durable equipment must be priced out and built into the settlement figure — not left on the table because the carrier's offer looked large.
Strength of the Evidence and Litigation Posture
Settlement value is inseparable from litigation risk. Cases backed by consistent treating-physician opinions, clear diagnostic findings, and a clean credibility record command more than cases with disputed liability or conflicting medical testimony. Understanding exactly where a case stands before negotiating is what separates an informed settlement from a pressured one.
Specific Loss Benefits Under Pennsylvania Law
Pennsylvania assigns a defined number of compensation weeks to the permanent loss of specific body parts and functions — and those benefits stack on top of wage loss claims. Amputations, permanent loss of use, significant hearing or vision loss, and serious disfigurement each carry their own schedule. Identifying every applicable specific loss entitlement is a step many injured workers and their representatives miss entirely.
Medicare Set-Aside Structuring
When a claimant is Medicare-eligible or reasonably expected to become so, federal law requires that a portion of the settlement be allocated to cover future work-injury-related medical costs before Medicare pays. Structuring this correctly protects the worker from future Medicare denials and affects both how the settlement is valued and how it is paid.
Third-Party Liability Claims
Workers' compensation is not always the only avenue for recovery. When a work injury results from the negligence of someone other than the employer — a machine manufacturer, a negligent motorist, a property owner — a separate civil lawsuit may run alongside the comp claim. Third-party recoveries frequently dwarf the workers' comp settlement and should be evaluated before any resolution is reached.
Why This Site Exists
Pennsylvania workers' compensation is a system designed by the insurance industry, administered by the state, and navigated by injured workers who have never seen it before. The information asymmetry is enormous. Insurance adjusters handle hundreds of claims a year. Injured workers handle one — their own — at the worst moment of their lives.
- To explain how PA workers' comp settlements are actually valued
- To show injured workers what real settlements look like — in real dollar amounts
- To identify the tactics carriers use to minimize payouts — and how to counter them
- To connect workers who need help with experienced representation
30+
Years of PA workers' comp experience
Thousands
of cases settled
Tens of Millions
recovered for injured PA workers
SettleMyCompCase.com is an informational resource. Nothing on this site constitutes legal advice or creates an attorney-client relationship. Every case is unique. Consult a licensed Pennsylvania attorney for advice specific to your situation.
Ready to Find Out What Your Case Is Worth?
Get a free, confidential case review from an attorney who has spent 30 years valuing Pennsylvania workers' compensation claims.
Get a Free Case Review